Rated 5 stars ***** First Square Fish (Farrar Straus Giroux, Macmillan). 2024. 304 p.
Open, raw, honest prose fills nonbinary George Johnson’s memoir through memories of growing up Black and Queer in a small New Jersey town. The love and support received from their parents, extended family members, and their beloved grandmother are also detailed. Reasons why they suppressed their identity as they sorted out what it meant to know they weren’t like other boys, as well as the oppression they felt as a member of the Black community, are also part of their story. Johnson wants teen readers who are Black and Queer to see themselves. As the title suggests, all boys are not the same because they are not all stereotypical blue. Some might be a little pink or an entirely different color and should be able to live freely.
Recommended for ages 15 and older.
I met George Johnson at a recent conference and was impressed because they are articulate, well-versed, a spitfire, and an advocate for their community. This is the #2 banned book in the United States due to its graphic content, but its message is important. Banning a book because it’s eyebrow raising content doesn’t measure up to a book banner’s point of view does a huge disservice to its intended audience. Erasing a book erases a reader’s identity, and no one deserves to be erased.